Back to ISMICS Main Site
 


Quick Links
   Home
Loading

 



Back to 2014 Annual Meeting Display Posters


Ministernotomy versus median sternotomy for isolated aortic valve replacement: is it time to define a new gold standard?
Laurence Carole Ngo Yon, Pasquale Totaro, Alessandro Mazzola.
Cardiothoracic Surgery, IRCCS Foundation San Matteo, Pavia, Italy.

OBJECTIVE: Minimally invasive cardiac surgery (MICS) is not considered yet as gold standard for cardiac surgery procedures. Based on our extensive experience using MICS procedures(>1500 patients) here we try to elucidate if ministernotomy (MI) can be considerede as gold standard for isolated AVR compared to median sternotomy (MS).
METHODS: Out of a general population of > 2000 patients undergone isolated AVR, 62 patients were randomized to receive MI or MS approach. Patients were homogeneous in terms of preoperative parameters including Euroscore. Intraoperative data (extracorporeal circulation and cross-clamp times, pH, BE, TC°) were analyzed and compared using unpaired t-test. Early postoperative outcomes were analyzed using both SOFA and SAPS II ICU admission risk scores plus standard clinical parameters.
RESULTS: Analysis of intraoperative parameters (Fig 1a) showed no differences in terms of mean extracorporeal circulation and cross-clamp times between two groups. Furthermore analysis of metabolic intraoperative parameters showed a significant better preservation of metabolic status (Ph analysis) in MI group (Fig 1b). Early postoperative outcome in terms of ICU admission risk score was also no significantly different (SOFA and SAPS II 3.80 ± 2.39 and 20 ± 8 for MI and 3.58 ± 2.71 and 24 ± 8 for MS respectively). As far as clinical postoperative parameters were concerned, despite mean postoperative ventilation time, incidence of prolonged ventilation and ICU stay and total lenght of stay were all in favour of MI , the difference did not reached statistical significance.
CONCLUSIONS: Our experience shows that ministernotomy is a reproducible, effective approach who can be performed safely, compared with sternotomy approach for an aortic valve surgery without surgical time differences. Despite the difficulties in showing statistical differences in early clinical outcome, due to the low incidence of complications, the advantages in terms of reduced invasively and preservation of physiological status combined with psychological advantages which become relevant in the long term follow-up, make this approach, in our mind, the gold standard for isolated AVR.

Download ePoster


Back to 2014 Annual Meeting Display Posters
 
© 2026 International Society for Minimally Invasive Cardiothoracic Surgery. All Rights Reserved. Read Privacy Policy.